MELBOURNE AIRPORT review : 27 May 2009 : by S Turton
|
Customer Rating : 2/5 |  |
Touting by limo drivers at T1 & T2 early morning and late evening has become a real pain for
arriving passengers. It is illegal, the public announcements say so, and the signs say so, but
the airport is doing nothing visible to stop these pushy touts hassling arriving passengers.
The airport has extensive video surveillance, they can see what is happening, but they don't
are. Makes Melbourne look like a 3rd world airport. With the lack of proper public transport
options they will unfortunately persist!
MELBOURNE AIRPORT review : 27 February 2009 : by Marshall Davies
|
Customer Rating : 2/5 |  |
Recently had the slowest arrival experience of any international flights my wife and I have
taken over the past 15 years - including our previous arrivals at Melbourne. We disembarked at
about 2220 & collected our luggage at the carousel at 2245. Ominously, there were
approximately 150 people queued for Customs when we first arrived at the carousel. By the time
passengers from our flight had collected their luggage, there was a single queue that snaked
twice around carousel 1 before feeding into the existing three lines of people who had been
waiting when we arrived. As we waited patiently, passenger from another flight collected their
bags & joined the queues. It took until 2345 to reach a Customs Officer & be waved though
after a quick check of our luggage. I don't blame Customs staff who were obviously doing their
best with patience & good humour, but seeing almost everyone being asked to open their cases,
I could understand the delays. I doubt whether too many people waiting to clear Customs that
night would have any positive thoughts about Melbourne Airport or maybe Melbourne & Australia,
in general. Either there needs to be more Customs Officers on duty or some further risk
analysis needs to be undertaken with a view to limiting searches of suitcases to a much
smaller proportion than was carried out while we were there.
MELBOURNE AIRPORT review : 16 February 2009 : by Eric Simpson
|
Customer Rating : 3/5 |  |
Passing through Melbourne on two occasions as a transit passenger was a disappointing
experience. The arrival pier was shabby and in need of re-carpeting and decoration. Only on
reaching the arrivals duty free area did the appearance of the airport improve. Transit
passengers were required to negotiate what appeared to be poorly finished service corridors
and stairs in order to reach the departures security search area. The departure area itself
was attractive with a good range of duty free outlets, unfortunately the toilets were in need
of some deep cleaning.
MELBOURNE AIRPORT review : 7 February 2009 : by Simon Smith
|
Customer Rating : 2/5 |  |
I flew out of Melbourne on a Qantas domestic flight. The airport works OK, with little queue
for check in or security, but it looks in need of modernisation. My main issue was that the
food and drink options airside were awful. There are lots of different outlets, all with
different branding, but they all sell the same products for the same prices. I bought a
sandwich which was stale, a chocolate muffin which tasted more of banana, and a coffee which
was cold - and this cost nearly $20. Eat before you get to the airport.
MELBOURNE AIRPORT review : 18 November 2008 : by J Potter
|
Customer Rating : 4/5 |  |
One of the most annoying things about this airport is the very high cost of short term parking which
is $45 a day. This is more than a car park in central Melbourne. There is an undercover "Long-term"
car park which is quite misleading. This car park charges the same as the short term car park
which it shares the building with. I have no idea what the discount applying is, and at $90
overnight, it is expensive. I agree with the comments about baggage and customs delays, but there
again this is an island nation and we think every one wants to come here. The domestic terminals
are quite decent but then there is no immigration or much baggage there.
MELBOURNE AIRPORT review : 9 November 2008 : by E Carew
|
Customer Rating : 3/5 |  |
While I understand the arguments an airline operator might make about the need to make a return on
its lease, Melbourne Airport's continued refusal to install free Internet terminals (emulating
Singapore) is poor. Singapore may be essentially a government-run airport, but Melbourne is boring
by comparison and it is about time that passengers were offered a small 'freebie' given the various
airport charges that are included in the prices of most tickets. Of course it would be unfair to
claim that Melbourne Airport is the only Australian airport to fall behind progressive transport
hubs like Changi Airport. While Melbourne Airport's per-passenger processing fees are lower than
most other Australian capital city airports, it ought to give something back to passengers who
contribute a huge daily amount in parking fees and indirectly in airport income by supporting
overpriced shops that block one's way once airside in the international terminal, as others have
observed. There seems to be a lack of drinking water fountains in the Virgin Blue terminal,
unforgivable in an often warm to hot climate like Melbourne's (in summer and early autumn at least)
and another attempt to force us all to purchase bottled water should we forget to bring non-
alcoholic drinks from home, office or hotel.
MELBOURNE AIRPORT review : 7 November 2008 : by K Goshalia
|
Customer Rating : 3/5 |  |
The security and immigration was not very long departing Melbourne taking a red eye flight to
Singapore. The whole idea of passing the duty free to move to the gate area seems a little pushy to
passengers. This leaves a feeling of aggressive selling on the minds of passengers. Once you pass
the duty free shops to the gate area there is nothing much to do except just waiting at the gate
area.No decent bar/dining area to relax before a flight. Unlike major airports worldwide there is no
lounge access even on payment for travellers using non-premium cabins.
MELBOURNE AIRPORT review : 15 October 2008 : by A Jafarzadeh
|
Customer Rating : 3/5 |  |
Have flown in and out of Tullamarine International four times and every time I've been left wanting.
Arriving in Melbourne is a tiring and tedious process with inefficient immigrations and customs
procedures. Getting out of the building an hour after touchdown is the best you can hope for,
especially if you're arriving with another international flight. When leaving Melbourne, make sure
you grab something to eat before you go airside because there is quite literally nothing once you're
through unless you fancy a dodgy sandwich bar with grumpy teenagers behind the counter or an
overpriced "wine bar" that would be better suited to downtown Melbourne than an airport where most
people just want something well-priced and appetising. I'm not much of a fan of fast food joints but
even a Hungry Jacks would be welcome in the departure lounge. Pretty much nothing to do when waiting
for your flight so bring a book or time it so you don't have long to wait after clearing security.
For Australia's second biggest city Tullamarine is not doing Melbourne any favours and desperately
needs more airside.
MELBOURNE AIRPORT review : 7 October 2008 : by G Hailey
|
Customer Rating : 1/5 |  |
Customs extremely slow. we were forced to go into foreigners line and wait for 45 minutes -
finally got to the overcrowded baggage area. seems Melbourne patronage has outgrown the airports
capabilities - waited 30 mins for the luggage to come and then ended up in a queue that stretched
up and around and down the baggage carousels and then had to wait nearly 1 hour to get through
baggage scanning. The demands on this airport have far exceeded what this airport and its
facilities are capable of. The arrivals area is clearly lacking and has clearly been forgotten
about in any development to increase its handling capabilities.
MELBOURNE AIRPORT review : 6 October 2008 : by R Dowling
|
Customer Rating : 3/5 |  |
Arrived back at international terminal few days ago and got through the whole 'plane to airport bus
exercise in a record 40 minutes. The secret - very quiet, no other arrival in sight. Generally by
far the slowest airport in the world from which to deplane. Baggage carousel a lousy old fashioned
design, and it takes for ever for the baggage to even get to the carousel. (I think QANTAS does all
international baggage). More than one flight per hour and the carousel is crowded with a lot of
anxious pax who fight for space to grab their bags. Then the paranoid inspired quarantine queue
which stretches almost back to the 'plane itself at times. Usually takes 60 minutes or more to get
out of the place. Still, what can you expect from a glorified mini shopping mall aka as Tullamarine
airport?
MELBOURNE AIRPORT review : 3 September 2008 : by R West
|
Customer Rating : 1/5 |  |
The international baggage hall is a dark and gloomy place to wait 65 minutes for luggage to come off
the lane - but that's my most recent experience there. The waiting time was interspersed with
announcements from airlines apologising to passengers for baggage delays - it seems to be a
widespread problem. After picking up your bags, it's much better to avoid the long quarantine queue
where luggage is checked - so don't bring anything in (eg, foodstuffs, or anything made of wood),
that would cause you to be placed into that line. In my case, it took me more than two hours from
disembarkation to catching a taxi - not good enough.
MELBOURNE AIRPORT review : 27 August 2008 : by D Mascarenhas
|
Customer Rating : 2/5 |  |
Departed from Melbourne using Qantas to Mumbai via Sydney. What's surprising is that one needs to
pay for trolleys at both the departure and the arrival. Wonder whether passengers arriving first
time or even Australians need to be reminded to carry 2 x $2 coins both for out and incoming flight
fso they can pay for trolleys. I have a 4 month old infant and had to walk all the way up to the
taxi rank on the other side to get a trolley some passenger had left behind before jumping into a
cab.
MELBOURNE AIRPORT review : 30 July 2008 : by T Higson
|
Customer Rating : 4/5 |  |
Travelling with Qantas domestic with a group of footballers. For just about all of us, it was the
first time we had been to Melbourne Airport and yet we went straight to the bagge claim without
losing our way at all. It was a bit of a walk from gate 9 (I think) and our bags were there as we
arrived at the claim area. On our return, security took only two minutes during the evening peek
hour. There is a range of fast food outlets after security. We boarded at gate 2, one of the closest
gates but it was still a fair walk compared to such airports like Brisbane. There are not many seats
at the gate; but still more than some gates at Sydney. Clean airport, straight on the highway on
arrival - 4s tars
MELBOURNE AIRPORT review : 29 July 2008 : by N Nasev
|
Customer Rating : 2/5 |  |
MEL used to be a great airport. On previous occasions transferring from domestic to international
sections was a breeze. However, just now when a group of fellow travellers and myself followed the
signs to the international section from domestic, we ended up in a dead-end. Also, you have to weave
your way through a mass of duty-free retail areas to get through to the departure gate. I understand
that this is quite standard in many airports around the world, but Melbourne has taken this approach
way beyond a tolerable level. The worst experience of all was when I realised that I had left my
mobile phone behind at the security screening area. When I tried asking the security official who
was stationed at the lane I passed through whether he had seen my mobile, he deliberately ignored me
and pretended that I was not even there! This is a clear indication of the attitude this airport has
to its users.
MELBOURNE AIRPORT review : 19 June 2008 : by N Salmon
|
Customer Rating : 2/5 |  |
I'm a Melburnian and my recent trip through our airport was the second time I've felt let down. With
four international flights arriving at once you'd expect a few queues but those in charge are
clearly oblivious to the term 'customer service'. I'd just come through the much-maligned Heathrow
and it was a far better experience. The line through quarantine was enormous and slow moving with no
blue-shirted staff to hand to offer assistance. One passenger near me was trying in vain to connect
to a domestic flight and another guy was hassled by the previously invisible staff for jumping the
barrier to take his little boy to the toilet on the far side of the baggage hall. It took 95 minutes
from gate to taxi rank and all international arrivals have just endured at least an eight hour
flight. Can't be a great first impression for visitors.
MELBOURNE AIRPORT review : 7 May 2008 : by Edmund Carew
|
Customer Rating : 3/5 |  |
Ian Baker's comments about Australian quarantine are understandable. Yes, the queues for the 'red'
lane (something to declare) move too slowly sometimes. However while I sometimes get mildly annoyed
at having to declare processed foods like chocolate, the fact remains that Australia as the only
island continent is free of many diseases found in Europe, Asia and the US so quarantine is strict
as a result. Could the Australian Quarantine Inspection Service and Australian Customs improve their
processing times? Yes, but sometimes there may simply not be enough 'lanes' at the airport in
question. This is poor when one considers the massive amounts Australia's airports rake in from
travellers and rentals, and the Australian departure tax which is not cheap by world standards.
Melbourne Airport review by Nick Fortuna
15 March 2008 Customer Rating : 
Used MEL domestic and international on four occasions - Fri/Sat/Sun. The domestic airport works well
enough, though on arrival, the relevant baggage reclaim could do with better signposting. Handy that
the domestic international terminals are under the same roof, making transfers between the two much
more comfortable - Sydney take note! Plenty of shops, pleasant ambience, and during the times I used
the airport, not too busy. Announcements at the gate were hardly audible. One downside: the QANTAS
international first class lounge upstairs could use with much better air conditioning. During the
hot afternoon I was there, I saw three portable units rattling away in the supposedly rarified
atmosphere of an international-standard lounge.
Melbourne Airport review by G Wilson
14 March 2008 Customer Rating : 
Domestic terminal (Virgin Blue & Rex) Check-in for VB fine, but Rex not signposted. Asked staff &
was helped, no problem. Signage for Rex was waist-high beside check in desk! Perhaps they dont want
to be found. Long walk to Rex gate & not much to see or do - but it gets the job done.
Melbourne Airport review by Ian Baker
12 March 2008 Customer Rating : 
Arrived evening Sunday 2 March from Bangkok. Long wait for luggage. Then extremely slow queue for
baggage to go through Quarantine. Maybe 90 minutes from getting off the plane to being able to leave
the airport. Why do all passengers have to go through Quarantine with their baggage? It does not
happen elsewhere. If the facility is inadequate - as the slowness illustrates - the authority should
select persons to go to Quarantine who are considered 'risky' and let others leave at once.
Melbourne Airport review by S Dobson
21 February 2008 Customer Rating : 
Arrived Melbourne international just after the morning rush at 10am. About 2 other flights being
processed and queue for immigration long, although flowed smoothly. Didnt help with having inwards
duty free where it was. Bags not far behind but arrival hall chaotic. Queue for red exit snaked
back through the baggage carousels and took nearly 1.5 hours to be seen by Quarantine. Overheard a
few altercations between other pax re queue jumping and more than a few comments about the delays
and crowded conditions. International arrivals needs more space and staff to cope with peak
periods, especially when the A380 starts services. Staff tried their best to help get people moving
but seemed to be overwhelmed with it all. Like all airports peak periods are busy but Melbourne
seemed to be bursting at the seams - if you have a choice avoid arriving in the morning.
Melbourne Airport review by J Ralley
14 November 2007 Customer Rating : 
When we flew out July 2007 they were still randomly weighing hand luggage before going through
passport control. Travelling with a 10 month and 2.5 year old we tried to minimise our bags down to 2
but that meant our carry-on suitcase weighed about 11kg. Luckily we stood our ground and just kept
saying that it was for 4 people and in the end they let us through - obviously put it in the "too
hard" basket. But just be aware. Good airport otherwise. Not too much to do so don't get there too
early but otherwise clean and easy to get around.
Melbourne Airport review by M Duval
18 September 2007 Customer Rating : 
Used it a lot 2 years ago. Getting through customs/bagage claim can take a bit long sometimes compared
to European or asian airports. Not too big, so no long walks to gates, not too small to get bored at
either. Friendly laid back staff - one downside, with many Australian airports it's sometimes annoying
having to walk through a duty free shop to get to customs. As is often the case, a lot of duty free
shops are directly located in the path you have to walk through when leaving the gates and walking
towards customs and baggage claim.
Melbourne Airport review by T Huppatz
2 August 2007 Customer Rating : 
We fly frequently in and out of Melbourne. I think it depends on how
many planes are taking off or landing at the same time on how long it
takes to get thru customs or collecting luggage. Generally we have to
queue about 1/2 an hour for luggage. It is a modern, clean airport with
lots of cafes, restaurants and shops. Good signage and easy to get
around.
Melbourne Airport review by Alasdair Brooks
19 July 2007 Customer Rating : 
I flew out of Melbourne on United to LAX in mid-June 2007, and didn't
face the second weigh-in airside, nor did I see any sign of anyone else
being weighed airside. I'm not saying the two previous postings are
wrong, but it would seem that - as of mid-2007 - this wasn't being
applied consistently. And is airside in Melbourne's international
terminal the only place in Australia with Irn Bru vending machines?
What an odd experience it was to see Scotland's favourite soft drink on
sale in dedicated vending machines in Melbourne.
Melbourne Airport review by Edmund Carew
31 December 2006 Customer Rating : n/a
T Kelly (27/12) is correct about the second 'weigh-in' immediately upon
entering airside, but I've found if you are travelling as an individual
and enter the area straight after a family or others, you can escape
your hand luggage being weighed. Given the amount of duty free some
passengers buy later prior to boarding, this weighing seems superflous
and petty bureaucracy at its worst.
Melbourne Airport review by T Kelly
27 December 2006
Decent enough medium-sized airport, but beware: MEL (International)
enforces luggage weight restrictions to the letter. Not satisfied with
just the regular weigh-in of both checked and hand luggage at check-in,
your hand luggage is weighed again upon entering passport control.
Depending on staff on the day, exceeding the limit by a mere couple of
hundred grams could have you on your knees in front of everyone removing
contents from your bag until they satisfy said staff member. Not the
happiest way to leave the country. The second weigh-in at passport
control was new to me, as I had never encountered this at other
Australian international airports. Always long lines at immigration.
When leaving Australia, after passport control, Duty Free is
inescapable..... you have to walk through it to reach the departure
lounge. Shameless. Departure area makes you feel a little "hemmed in":
after the inescapable duty free, there is a long corridor similar to the
Virgin Blue terminal, with shops on either side. Towards the end, the
space becomes round with seating areas, cafe, newsagents, etc. This area
feels very crowded when several flights are departing at around the same
time. Overall, a decent enough international airport, but staff attitude
could often be improved, and if departing from MEL, do watch your
luggage weight to avoid public humiliation!!
Melbourne Airport review by Mike Langran
21 June 2006
Arrived from SIN and what a delight! No queues at immigration or
customs. Bags came off quickly thanks to priority tags. Loved the
Commonwealth Games arrival carpet - decked out for the 100m! Really
pleasant arrival and on our way in next to no time. Staff pleasant and
friendly.
Melbourne Airport review by Peter Snow
20 April 2006
My wife and I travelled outward through Tullamarine on Saturday 15 April. Check-in for Air NZ was a
breeze, admittedly with Koru Club membership, and Immigration and Security with no queues at all.
New Air NZ Lounge looks excellent but spoilt by children screaming most of the time (not crying but
playing). Certainly not an oasis! Used the shuttle bus from downtown, and most impressed. Pickup near hotel right on time, and only
20 minutes to airport from Southern Cross Terminus - cannot do much better than that in a cab at
three times the price.
Melbourne Airport review by A Kattula
12 April 2006
Had not been through international terminal since 1994! Terminal is a
credit to Melbourne with fast check in and efficient immigration
outbound. Admittedly it was 6am on a Saturday! Plenty of shops and clean
facilities airside. Prices in shops seemed quite reasonable.
Return through Qantas domestic terminal was again efficient but a long
walk from gate to baggage claim. Travellators would be appreciated by
many. Taxi supervisor arranged for maxi cab due party of 4 with large
baggage without any delay. Overall a fantastic airport to use!
Melbourne Airport review by Jeffrey Leong
27 March 2006
I was surprised that Mark Stoneham had been told to get rid of his
chocolates upon arrival in Australia from London. I had some chocolates
in my pocket which I had only realised I had on me upon arrival (in
Sydney, not Melbourne). I asked one of the customs officers whether I
should throw them away or not. She indicated that it was alright to
bring them in as they were only chocolates. Different officers,
different standards, with one more understanding than the other perhaps?
As for checking in, I do not know about international flights but for
domestic flights at Tullamarine Airport for me was very quick indeed.
What surprised me about the airport was how relatively expensive it was
to take the bus service from Tullamarine to downtown Melbourne - AUD15
one way. Compared to neighbouring Sydney, it cost only AUD15 for a
return ticket. on the minibus service from the airport door-to-door to a
hotel in downtown Sydney.
Melbourne Airport review by Mark Stoneham
9 February 2006
On the whole it is a stress-free experience. It is light and airy and
very clean. plenty of shops and good duty free. Also plenty of
comfortable seating - however, every time I have left from Tulla, the
queues at immigration / passport control have been horrendous. Allow
plenty of time to go through and get to your gate. The very first time I
left Tulla I almost missed my flight home! Also, check in queues can be
trying and slow, though this could depend on your airline. This February
I was flying up to Singapore with BA on the first leg of my homeward
journey to London. They were checking in more than one flight at our
desk and as a result, I began to woder if I'd reach the check in desk
before my scheduled departure time. I explained my predicament to two
officials who told me to be patient and were not at all worried on my
behalf. The third kindly took me to another desk where I checked in
immediately - then went to join the aforementioned immigration queue! My
final comment - the first time I arrived in Melbourne, I was unaware of
the laws regarding bringing foodstuffs into the country - in my case
chocolate. The very first Australian official I met told me in his own
inimitable fashion that I was breaking the law and to 'Get rid of it!'
Welcome to Australia!
IMPORTANT NOTE
Comments and opinions contained in these pages do not represent the views of Skytrax. All features contain unsolicited input from site visitors, and we
seek to exercise the minimum level of editorial control and censorship to ensure the widest debate and platform for customer opinions. We
will not publish submissions that contain abusive language. We cannot guarantee to publish all opinions submitted.
ADD YOUR COMMENTS HERE
These Review pages are designed to offer guidance and assistance to other travellers, and we ask
respondents to use an "informative" style of comment and share any travel tips for the airport in question.
Your First Name (or initial) and Family Name, and E-mail address MUST be supplied.
When submitting comments, please DO NOT insert paragraphs.
Please check you use Upper and Lower case only - submissions made all in CAPITALS will
NOT be accepted.
Comment submissions that require extensive text editing CANNOT be published.
|